Something I'm sort of tired of seeing
is that illustrators should be payed like plumbers. Why?
The problem is that illustrators think
that they need to be paid. How much should you pay? The quick version
is: It depends. Assuming a reasonably new artist, you should pay
about $100 for a page (8.5"x11") of black & white art,
or $250 for colored, regardless of medium. That assumes a piece of
art that is finished; if it's just the rough art, where someone else
needs to ink it, more like $50-$100. On the other hand, if you want
the person to letter it, add $50; lettering may only take a few
minutes, but there is some serious graphic design skills involved.
So, assuming a full page of art, a person should be charged $50 to
$300 minimum. If, on the other your project is bigger or smaller, pay
appropriately; a full comic (assuming 20 pages) is easily in the
neighborhood of $2000 to $5000, while a quarter-page (4"x5"
or so) should be $25 to $60. For a seasoned artist, or even a famous
one, that number really starts to escalate, so that keep that in
mind.
However, that's the quick version.
Here's my problem: An illustrator is not a plumber. A plumber does
something specific that you need done, and without which life gets
very complicated very quickly. Try not taking a shower for a week or
realize that you cannot do something as simple as keep your house
clean because of a lack of water. I need water; I don't need art.
More to the point, if the plumber does not do his job, I can sue him
and he is likely to get fired. However, an illustrator is hired in
the hopes that he will do the job and make the comic come alive; an
illustrator is hired on speculation of his doing a great job, whereas
a plumber isn't. This should not be offensive to illustrators; art
will always be based on how people like it and not how they do it as
long as someone continues to like it. Seriously: If you saw a plumber
pull out anything but a snake and a wrench and start working on your
pipes with a large club, how long would that plumber be in your
house? So stop with the plumbers and illustrators analogy; I get
that illustrators need to get paid. But that's the only thing they
have in common with plumbers.
The other problem is that writers and
illustrators look at things differently. Screw the education factor;
I see one more illustrator complain that he should be paid because he
has a single Masters degree I will seriously debate putting out a hit
on him. If you compared writers to illustrators, you would quickly
find that writers have taken more classes and picked up more degrees
than the average illustrator; most illustrators have pretty much just
the art degree, whereas writers usually have a degree in something
else, and then have to go back to school for the writing classes.
The problem is that writers are used to
doing on spec. Illustrators are truly fortunate; they can find
someone hiring, take their college work in a portfolio to the
interview, and possibly get a job where they are paid for what they
are told what to make; that is, you have a contract for work. "Spec"
is where you put a year plus into something and hope someone pays
you; let's just say there is a reason authors love print on demand.
It gets worse when you realize that, in order to get some of the best
writing jobs, you need to go through some pretty weird hoops. Try to
become a decently paid screenwriter; in order to get paid even scale,
you need to write AND get paid for a motion picture script (or
equivalent, such as four half-hour shows) before you can join the
Writer's Guild of America, and you have to do this in an industry
where to have to be a WGA member in order to be able to even write a
movie script. The same applies in a number of industries, such as
comics. Getting paid is cool, but pretty much optional for most
writers.
Now keep in mind that there is a part
of us that think this "if you're going to make it in an
industry, you need to be known outside it first" mindset applies
to all artists. Ergo, we have no problem looking for illustrators
stressing that this can be great exposure; if we're doing something
for exposure, and that's how we get into the industry, why shouldn't
you? Making the case for us is that this is how the comics industry
actually works; you need to draw a decent comic before someone in the
industry will take you seriously. There are exceptions, such as
Kubert grads, but in general you need to show you can do a decent
comic before someone takes you seriously. Now, if you happen to be
one of the few decent writer/illustrators out there, this is not a
problem, but if you're just an average illustrator you're going to
team with a decent writer in order to create that decent book in
order to be taken seriously; you can't just put something together
and hope, because if the writing sucks, they'll likely toss the book
quickly, and there goes your chance. The logic is pretty basic: omics
are still dependent on the story, and great artwork only gets you so
far. If you can't put together a decent book, which means a decent
story, then the artwork, no matter how great DOES NOT MATTER.
So...where does that leave us? Oh.
Right. Illustrators need to get paid. But...there can be times when
you need the exposure in order to show that you can draw a decent
book if you want to be a comic book artist, and a free job MAY do
that for you. So, when you are presented with a writer looking for
free art, debate it. Only if the story really grabs you should you go
for it. IF (Note: Big if, not a little one) you decide to go for it,
bargain hard for half the profit, and then go for it. But don't get
into the habit; do it once or twice, and then stop. I mean, you do
need to get paid, right? Right.